Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) Football Indianapolis Colts Sports Trading Cards & Accessories

Shop by Category

13,591 Results

2023 Panini Donruss Football PSA Graded Rookie Cards
New (Other) · Panini
$20.00 to $100.00
$4.38 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
New Listing1998 Bowman's Best #112 Peyton Manning HOF RC Rookie Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT
New (Other) · Bowman
$95.99
or Best Offer
$4.99 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
New Listing2023 Mosaic ANTHONY RICHARDSON Green Mosaic Prizm Rookie #282 PSA 10 GEM MINT 💎
New (Other)
$89.99
or Best Offer
$6.95 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
2023 Mosaic Anthony Richardson Reactive Blue Prizm NFL Debut #ND-5 Rookie PSA 10
New (Other)
$79.99
$5.00 shipping
13 watching
SponsoredSponsored Ad
$1999 Bowman's Best Marvin Harrison #62 PSA 9 Refractor /400$
1999 Bowman's Best Marvin Harrison #62 PSA 9 Refractor /400
New (Other) · Topps
$10.01
$4.99 shipping
4 bids
2h 39m
2023 Panini Illusions - Light Blue #46 Anthony Richardson /199 Rookie PSA 8
New (Other) · Panini
$5.50
$4.99 shipping
4 bids
2h 43m
2023 Panini Donruss ANTHONY RICHARDSON Season Stat Line /500 Indianapolis COLTS
New (Other) · Panini
$10.00
$5.55 shipping
12 bids
3h 22m
2022 Mosaic NEBULA Reggie Wayne 1/1 PSA 9 MINT True 1 OF 1 Colts #241
New (Other) · Panini
$250.00
$4.47 shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
1 bid
6h 17m
New Listing1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Base Rookie Card RC #165 PSA 9 Colts
New (Other) · Topps
(2)
$1.00
$4.38 shipping
0 bids
6d 17h
New Listing2023 Prizm Anthony Richardson Portals Green PSA 10
New (Other) · Panini
$50.00
or Best Offer
$3.96 shipping
New ListingPeyton Manning 1998 UD Choice Reserve Rookie Card #193 PSA 9 Mint SP RC
New (Other) · Upper Deck
$32.99
or Best Offer
$4.99 shipping
2019 Impeccable Montana/Favre/Manning/Brady Quad Auto /5 PSA 9 - POP 1
New (Other)
$9,200.00
or Best Offer
$4.00 shipping
10 watching
Authenticity Guarantee
New Listing2023 Panini Donruss - Press Proof Red #343 Anthony Richardson (RC) PSA 8
New (Other) · Panini
$17.00
or Best Offer
$4.43 shipping
New Listing1998 Upper Deck Choice Peyton Manning HOF ROOKIE RC #193 PSA 10 GEM MINT
New (Other) · Upper Deck
$61.99
or Best Offer
$4.99 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
Peyton Manning 2021 Obsidian Color Blast Black Signed Card #CB16 PSA 68343629
Pre-Owned · Panini
$599.99
or Best Offer
Free shipping
10 watching
SponsoredSponsored Ad
1999 Topps Stars Peyton Manning Starcards 1 Star Rainbow /299 #23 PSA 9 SP Pop 1
New (Other) · Topps
$149.95
or Best Offer
$5.90 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
2023 Panini Prizm #343 ANTHONY RICHARDSON Rookie GOLD Prizm #d /10 PSA Authentic
New (Other) · Panini
$10,999.00
or Best Offer
$20.00 shipping
18 watching
Authenticity Guarantee
2000 Collector's Edge Graded MARVIN HARRISON #147 Uncirculated PSA 9 /5000
New (Other) · Collector's Edge
$0.99
$3.86 shipping
1 bid
6h 5m
Peyton Manning 2000 Collectors Edge Uncirculated Card #150 Graded PSA 9 Mint
New (Other) · Collector's Edge
$7.99
$5.45 shipping
1998 Leaf Rookie & Stars Rookie #270 Peyton Manning DGA 9 Mint Colts
New (Other) · Leaf
$5.50
Free shipping
7 bids
20h 17m
2023 Panini Prizm Anthony Richardson #343 Red White Blue PSA 9 Mint Rookie Qty
New (Other) · Panini
$54.99
or Best Offer
$6.15 shipping
New Listing2016 Panini Donruss Pat McAfee #131 PSA 10 Gem Mint Indianapolis Colts
Consign with us! Sign Up & Get Started @ dcsports87-com
New (Other)
$5.75
$4.75 shipping
2 bids
4d 8h
New Listing1998 Bowman’s Best Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning #112 PSA 9
New (Other) · Bowman
$31.99
or Best Offer
$4.99 shipping
New ListingAnthony Richardson 2023 Panini Donruss #BS1 RC Bomb Squad PSA 10
New (Other) · Panini
$60.00
or Best Offer
$3.96 shipping
New Listing1994 Skybox Impact Rookie Redemption #2 Marshall Faulk Rookie Redemption PSA 10
New (Other) · SkyBox
$500.00
or Best Offer
Free shipping
New Listing2016 Panini Donruss Pat McAfee #131 PSA 9 Mint Indianapolis Colts
Consign with us! Sign Up & Get Started @ dcsports87-com
New (Other)
$0.99
$4.75 shipping
0 bids
4d 8h
2023 Black Box Jonathan Taylor Rookie 20 Optic Auto Gold Vinyl 1/1 PSA 10/10 J1S
New (Other) · Panini
$2,000.00
or Best Offer
$30.00 shipping
13 watching
2000 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #56 PSA 9 Mint HOF Indianapolis Colts
New (Other) · Topps
$18.00
or Best Offer
$3.84 shipping
2020 Panini Obsidian Rookie Auto Silver Michael Pittman Jr. RC Auto 16/150 PSA
New (Other)
$80.00
$5.15 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
2023 Panini Prizm Rookie Gold Vinyl Autograph Josh Downs /5 PSA 10
New (Other) · Panini
$212.00
$4.02 shipping
25 bids
3d 6h
SponsoredSponsored Ad
2020 Michael Pittman Jr. Panini Select Cosmic Prizm Rookie Colts PSA 10 Pop 4
New (Other) · Panini
$199.95
or Best Offer
Free shipping
10 watching
SponsoredSponsored Ad
ANTHONY RICHARDSON 2023 Panini Immaculate Collegiate Auto 8 /49 - Gators /Colts
New (Other) · Panini
$225.00
or Best Offer
$4.02 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
2023 Panini Spectra Anthony Richardson Rising Rookie Mat Neon Blue #48/50 PSA 10
New (Other) · Panini
$51.00
$6.15 shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
3 bids
4h 59m
2023 Panini Prizm ANTHONY RICHARDSON Silver Rookie RC #304 Colts PSA 8 NM-MT
New (Other) · Panini
$15.50
$14.99 shipping
3 bids
8h 28m
2023 Anthony Richardson Contenders Optic Rookie Ticket Auto/23 Prizm PSA 10 POP1
New (Other) · Panini
$1,850.00
Free shipping
Authenticity Guarantee
30 bids
10h 48m
2012 Panini Black T.Y. Hilton Auto #'d *rc* PSA 7 Rookie Signature Good Price
New (Other) · Panini
$20.00
or Best Offer
$5.00 shipping
2023 Panini Absolute Anthony Richardson Rookie #104 Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT!
New (Other) · Panini
$30.00
or Best Offer
$6.54 shipping
2020 Panini Illusions Jonathan Taylor Rookie Card PSA 9 #14 Indianapolis Colts
New (Other) · Panini
$1.25
$5.19 shipping
2 bids
10h 27m
2013 Fleer Retro #20 Peyton Manning 1998-99 Tradition Electrifying Auto PSA/DNA
Pre-Owned · Fleer
$249.99
or Best Offer
$5.90 shipping
11 watching
SponsoredSponsored Ad
JONATHAN TAYLOR 2022 Mosaic Stained Glass #GM-13 SSP Case Hit PSA 10💎 Gem Mint
New (Other) · Panini
$149.95
or Best Offer
$4.95 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
2023 ANTHONY RICHARDSON rc Donruss Football BOMB SQUAD rookie insert PSA 10 BS-1
New (Other) · Donruss
$48.48
Free shipping
Only 1 left!
New Listing2023 PANINI PRIZM ANTHONY RICHARDSON RED/WHITE/BLUE PSA 9 ROOKIE CARD COLTS ⭐️🔥
New (Other) · Panini
$0.99
$4.50 shipping
1 bid
6d 20h
Anthony Richardson 2023 Panini Prizm #PO-5 Portals Green Prizm Rookie PSA 10
New (Other) · Panini
$49.99
Free shipping
2023 PANINI PHOENIX JOSH DOWNS ROOKIE AUTO RPA ORANGE /99 COLTS PSA 8
New (Other) · Panini
$15.50
$5.55 shipping
5 bids
9h 4m
2023 Panini Prizm Prizm Break #PB4 Anthony Richardson Prizm Break-Green PSA 10
New (Other) · Panini
$50.00
or Best Offer
$6.15 shipping
2023 Illusions Anthony Richardson Funkadelic Pink Acetate Rookie 306/399 PSA 10
New (Other) · Panini
$36.00
$5.15 shipping
3 bids
8h 47m
2023 Mosaic Josh Downs No Huddle Blue auto psa 9
New (Other) · Panini
$35.00
$5.35 shipping
0 bids
2h 23m
1998 Upper Deck UD3 Football Peyton Manning Future Shock RC PSA 9 MINT
New (Other) · Upper Deck
$7.00
$4.31 shipping
4 bids
9h 33m
2023 Panini Illusions #2 Anthony Richardson Mystique PSA 9 Colts
New (Other) · Panini
$15.00
or Best Offer
$5.35 shipping
0 bids
16h 8m
New Listing2021 Contenders Football Peyton Manning Signs Of Greatness Auto #15/25 On Card
New (Other) · Panini
$2.25
$5.25 shipping
2 bids
6d
2023 Prizm Anthony Richardson Prizm Break RC #PB-4 PSA 10 Gem Mint Rookie Colts
New (Other) · Panini
$5.50
$4.68 shipping
4 bids
6h 3m
New Listing2023 Panini Prizm #343 Anthony Richardson (RC) PSA 9
New (Other) · Panini
$25.00
or Best Offer
$4.36 shipping
2023 Prizm Anthony Richardson Orange Lazer PSA 9 MINT #343 RC Rookie - COLTS
New (Other) · Panini
$48.50
$3.79 shipping
New ListingPAT McAFEE 2017 PANINI CERTIFIED CERTIFIED ACCOMPLISHMENTS PSA 9
New (Other) · Panini
$9.99
$5.99 shipping
0 bids
9d 7h
2021 select ZEBRA Peyton Manning SSP #35 Indianapolis Colts MVP HOF Case Hit
New (Other) · Select
$45.00
or Best Offer
$3.96 shipping
0 bids
10h 12m
Alec Pierce RC 2022 Select Rookie Sig Mem Blue Prizm PSA 10 Color Match POP 2
New (Other) · Select
$18.50
$5.35 shipping
7 bids
7h 17m
Reggie Wayne Blue Die Cut/50 PSA GEM 10
New (Other) · Panini
$20.00
$5.15 shipping
0 bids
2d 9h
1994 SP Marshall Faulk Foil #3 PSA 8 NM-MT HOF Colts
New (Other) · Upper Deck
$0.99
or Best Offer
$5.55 shipping
0 bids
8h 23m
2022 IMMACULATE JONATHAN TAYLOR #PPAJTS PREMIUM AUTO PATCH /25 PSA 9
New (Other) · Panini
$150.00
or Best Offer
$4.95 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad
2022 Panini Prizm JONATHAN TAYLOR #122 Red Shimmer #/35 Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT
New (Other) · Panini
$175.00
or Best Offer
$4.95 shipping
SponsoredSponsored Ad

Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) Football Indianapolis Colts Sports Trading Cards & Accessories

Shop by Category

13,591 Results

2023 Panini Donruss Football PSA Graded Rookie Cards

New Listing1998 Bowman's Best #112 Peyton Manning HOF RC Rookie Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT

New Listing2023 Mosaic ANTHONY RICHARDSON Green Mosaic Prizm Rookie #282 PSA 10 GEM MINT 💎

2023 Mosaic Anthony Richardson Reactive Blue Prizm NFL Debut #ND-5 Rookie PSA 10

1999 Bowman's Best Marvin Harrison #62 PSA 9 Refractor /400

2023 Panini Illusions - Light Blue #46 Anthony Richardson /199 Rookie PSA 8

2023 Panini Donruss ANTHONY RICHARDSON Season Stat Line /500 Indianapolis COLTS

2022 Mosaic NEBULA Reggie Wayne 1/1 PSA 9 MINT True 1 OF 1 Colts #241

New Listing1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Base Rookie Card RC #165 PSA 9 Colts

New Listing2023 Prizm Anthony Richardson Portals Green PSA 10

New ListingPeyton Manning 1998 UD Choice Reserve Rookie Card #193 PSA 9 Mint SP RC

2019 Impeccable Montana/Favre/Manning/Brady Quad Auto /5 PSA 9 - POP 1

New Listing2023 Panini Donruss - Press Proof Red #343 Anthony Richardson (RC) PSA 8

New Listing1998 Upper Deck Choice Peyton Manning HOF ROOKIE RC #193 PSA 10 GEM MINT

Peyton Manning 2021 Obsidian Color Blast Black Signed Card #CB16 PSA 68343629

1999 Topps Stars Peyton Manning Starcards 1 Star Rainbow /299 #23 PSA 9 SP Pop 1

2023 Panini Prizm #343 ANTHONY RICHARDSON Rookie GOLD Prizm #d /10 PSA Authentic

2000 Collector's Edge Graded MARVIN HARRISON #147 Uncirculated PSA 9 /5000

Peyton Manning 2000 Collectors Edge Uncirculated Card #150 Graded PSA 9 Mint

1998 Leaf Rookie & Stars Rookie #270 Peyton Manning DGA 9 Mint Colts

2023 Panini Prizm Anthony Richardson #343 Red White Blue PSA 9 Mint Rookie Qty

New Listing2016 Panini Donruss Pat McAfee #131 PSA 10 Gem Mint Indianapolis Colts

New Listing1998 Bowman’s Best Indianapolis Colts Peyton Manning #112 PSA 9

New ListingAnthony Richardson 2023 Panini Donruss #BS1 RC Bomb Squad PSA 10

New Listing1994 Skybox Impact Rookie Redemption #2 Marshall Faulk Rookie Redemption PSA 10

New Listing2016 Panini Donruss Pat McAfee #131 PSA 9 Mint Indianapolis Colts

2023 Black Box Jonathan Taylor Rookie 20 Optic Auto Gold Vinyl 1/1 PSA 10/10 J1S

2000 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #56 PSA 9 Mint HOF Indianapolis Colts

2020 Panini Obsidian Rookie Auto Silver Michael Pittman Jr. RC Auto 16/150 PSA

2023 Panini Prizm Rookie Gold Vinyl Autograph Josh Downs /5 PSA 10

2020 Michael Pittman Jr. Panini Select Cosmic Prizm Rookie Colts PSA 10 Pop 4

ANTHONY RICHARDSON 2023 Panini Immaculate Collegiate Auto 8 /49 - Gators /Colts

2023 Panini Spectra Anthony Richardson Rising Rookie Mat Neon Blue #48/50 PSA 10

2023 Panini Prizm ANTHONY RICHARDSON Silver Rookie RC #304 Colts PSA 8 NM-MT

2023 Anthony Richardson Contenders Optic Rookie Ticket Auto/23 Prizm PSA 10 POP1

2012 Panini Black T.Y. Hilton Auto #'d *rc* PSA 7 Rookie Signature Good Price

2023 Panini Absolute Anthony Richardson Rookie #104 Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT!

2020 Panini Illusions Jonathan Taylor Rookie Card PSA 9 #14 Indianapolis Colts

2013 Fleer Retro #20 Peyton Manning 1998-99 Tradition Electrifying Auto PSA/DNA

JONATHAN TAYLOR 2022 Mosaic Stained Glass #GM-13 SSP Case Hit PSA 10💎 Gem Mint

2023 ANTHONY RICHARDSON rc Donruss Football BOMB SQUAD rookie insert PSA 10 BS-1

New Listing2023 PANINI PRIZM ANTHONY RICHARDSON RED/WHITE/BLUE PSA 9 ROOKIE CARD COLTS ⭐️🔥

Anthony Richardson 2023 Panini Prizm #PO-5 Portals Green Prizm Rookie PSA 10

2023 PANINI PHOENIX JOSH DOWNS ROOKIE AUTO RPA ORANGE /99 COLTS PSA 8

2023 Panini Prizm Prizm Break #PB4 Anthony Richardson Prizm Break-Green PSA 10

2023 Illusions Anthony Richardson Funkadelic Pink Acetate Rookie 306/399 PSA 10

2023 Mosaic Josh Downs No Huddle Blue auto psa 9

1998 Upper Deck UD3 Football Peyton Manning Future Shock RC PSA 9 MINT

2023 Panini Illusions #2 Anthony Richardson Mystique PSA 9 Colts

New Listing2021 Contenders Football Peyton Manning Signs Of Greatness Auto #15/25 On Card

2023 Prizm Anthony Richardson Prizm Break RC #PB-4 PSA 10 Gem Mint Rookie Colts

New Listing2023 Panini Prizm #343 Anthony Richardson (RC) PSA 9

2023 Prizm Anthony Richardson Orange Lazer PSA 9 MINT #343 RC Rookie - COLTS

New ListingPAT McAFEE 2017 PANINI CERTIFIED CERTIFIED ACCOMPLISHMENTS PSA 9

2021 select ZEBRA Peyton Manning SSP #35 Indianapolis Colts MVP HOF Case Hit

Alec Pierce RC 2022 Select Rookie Sig Mem Blue Prizm PSA 10 Color Match POP 2

Reggie Wayne Blue Die Cut/50 PSA GEM 10

1994 SP Marshall Faulk Foil #3 PSA 8 NM-MT HOF Colts

2022 IMMACULATE JONATHAN TAYLOR #PPAJTS PREMIUM AUTO PATCH /25 PSA 9

2022 Panini Prizm JONATHAN TAYLOR #122 Red Shimmer #/35 Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT

You May Also Like

2012 Panini Black T.Y. Hilton Auto #'d rc PSA 7 Rookie Signature Good Price